Challenge: Using a Callable Object as a Method
In Python, when you use a callable object as a method within a class, there's a unique challenge you need to tackle. A callable object is something you can "call" like a function, such as a function itself or an object with a __call__
method. When used as a class method, it doesn't always work as expected due to how Python passes the instance (self
) as the first argument.
Let's explore this issue by creating a Stock
class. This class will represent a stock with attributes like name, number of shares, and price. We'll also use a validator to ensure the data we're working with is correct.
First, open the stock.py
file to start writing our Stock
class. You can use the following command to open the file in an editor:
code /home/labex/project/stock.py
Now, add the following code to the stock.py
file. This code defines the Stock
class with an __init__
method to initialize the stock's attributes, a cost
property to calculate the total cost, and a sell
method to reduce the number of shares. We'll also try to use the ValidatedFunction
to validate the input for the sell
method.
from validate import ValidatedFunction, Integer
class Stock:
def __init__(self, name, shares, price):
self.name = name
self.shares = shares
self.price = price
@property
def cost(self):
return self.shares * self.price
def sell(self, nshares: Integer):
self.shares -= nshares
## Try to use ValidatedFunction
sell = ValidatedFunction(sell)
After defining the Stock
class, we need to test it to see if it works as expected. Create a test file named test_stock.py
and open it using the following command:
code /home/labex/project/test_stock.py
Add the following code to the test_stock.py
file. This code creates an instance of the Stock
class, prints the initial number of shares and cost, tries to sell some shares, and then prints the updated number of shares and cost.
from stock import Stock
try:
## Create a stock
s = Stock('GOOG', 100, 490.1)
## Get the initial cost
print(f"Initial shares: {s.shares}")
print(f"Initial cost: ${s.cost}")
## Try to sell some shares
s.sell(10)
## Check the updated cost
print(f"After selling, shares: {s.shares}")
print(f"After selling, cost: ${s.cost}")
except Exception as e:
print(f"Error: {e}")
Now, run the test file using the following command:
python3 /home/labex/project/test_stock.py
You'll likely encounter an error similar to:
Error: missing a required argument: 'nshares'
This error occurs because when Python calls a method like s.sell(10)
, it actually calls Stock.sell(s, 10)
behind the scenes. The self
parameter represents the instance of the class, and it's automatically passed as the first argument. However, our ValidatedFunction
doesn't handle this self
parameter correctly because it doesn't know it's being used as a method.
Understanding the Problem
When you define a method inside a class and then replace it with a ValidatedFunction
, you're essentially wrapping the original method. The problem is that the wrapped method doesn't automatically handle the self
parameter correctly. It expects the arguments in a way that doesn't account for the instance being passed as the first argument.
Fixing the Problem
To fix this issue, we need to modify the way we handle methods. We'll create a new class called ValidatedMethod
that can handle method calls properly. Add the following code to the end of the validate.py
file:
import inspect
class ValidatedMethod:
def __init__(self, func):
self.func = func
self.signature = inspect.signature(func)
def __get__(self, instance, owner):
## This method is called when the attribute is accessed as a method
if instance is None:
return self
## Return a callable that binds 'self' to the instance
def method_wrapper(*args, **kwargs):
return self(instance, *args, **kwargs)
return method_wrapper
def __call__(self, instance, *args, **kwargs):
## Bind the arguments to the function parameters
bound = self.signature.bind(instance, *args, **kwargs)
## Validate each argument against its annotation
for name, val in bound.arguments.items():
if name in self.func.__annotations__:
## Get the validator class from the annotation
validator = self.func.__annotations__[name]
## Apply the validation
validator.check(val)
## Call the function with the validated arguments
return self.func(instance, *args, **kwargs)
Now, we need to modify the Stock
class to use ValidatedMethod
instead of ValidatedFunction
. Open the stock.py
file again:
code /home/labex/project/stock.py
Update the Stock
class as follows:
from validate import ValidatedMethod, Integer
class Stock:
def __init__(self, name, shares, price):
self.name = name
self.shares = shares
self.price = price
@property
def cost(self):
return self.shares * self.price
@ValidatedMethod
def sell(self, nshares: Integer):
self.shares -= nshares
The ValidatedMethod
class is a descriptor, which is a special type of object in Python that can change how attributes are accessed. The __get__
method is called when the attribute is accessed as a method. It returns a callable that correctly passes the instance as the first argument.
Run the test file again using the following command:
python3 /home/labex/project/test_stock.py
Now you should see output similar to:
Initial shares: 100
Initial cost: $49010.0
After selling, shares: 90
After selling, cost: $44109.0
This challenge has shown you an important aspect of callable objects. When using them as methods in a class, they require special handling. By implementing the descriptor protocol with the __get__
method, we can create callable objects that work correctly both as standalone functions and as methods.